Feds Shoot Down MDE Changes
MIRS, May 9,
For more articles like this
The U.S. Department of Education (USDOE) has rejected
portions of the Michigan Department of Education's (MDE) Annual
Yearly Progress (AYP) plans to meet the federal No Child Left
Behind (NCLB) requirements. As a result, the AYP school report
cards will be delayed, more schools will fail to meet the AYP
and the MDE is likely to be assessed financial penalties up to
$200,000 for 2007.
State Superintendent Mike FLANAGAN publicly announced the fed's
action today during the monthly State Board of Education
meeting, although the board members had been advised earlier.
The USDOE denied Michigan's request to increase the minimum
group size for certain subgroups of special needs students from
30 to a formula of 30 plus 10 percent of the total number of
This meant schools with say, 30 learning disabled students,
didn't have to report their test results as a specific subgroup.
That's one less category a school could be found not making AYP
in. If a school doesn't make AYP in one subgroup, the whole
school is labeled as not making adequate yearly progress.
The State Board of Education supported the different formula as
a way to provide equity between large and small schools, but the
USDOE didn't see it that way. They say that school of 30
learning disabled students now needs to report their progress as
a specific subgroup.
"Many more schools will not be making the AYP this year,"
Flanagan said. It will also require computer-programming changes
to calculate AYP. As a result there will be a delay in issuing
the report cards to elementary and middle schools.
MDE chief academic officer Jeremy HUGHES told the board there
would be about a one-to two-week delay in getting the report
cards out to the schools. The schools then have 10 days to
appeal the results. There is another 30 days under state law for
the school districts and the MDE to settle the appeals. This
means it will be late June before the information is available
to the public.
The USDOE also initially ruled that students who took the
special-needs "Participation and Supported Independence
MI-Access" tests could not be counted for the purpose of
calculating the minimum of 95 percent of the students tested.
That would have added many more schools and special education
center programs being labeled as not making AYP.
However, some further discussions by Flanagan and several
Michigan Congressional offices resulted in the USDOE
reconsidering, but not without consequences.
Michigan had the choice of an earlier denial or allowing the
assessments to be included, but be penalized by USDOE for not
meeting the deadline for having an approved plan by next fall.
Flanagan determined it was more appropriate for the MDOE to take
the financial penalty in order to protect local schools and
programs from being inappropriately labeled since the two
MI-Access assessments were administered in good faith by local
Flanagan called the denials "a slam to communities who operated
in good faith."
Although the MDE had received assistance and indications from
federal USDOE staff that Michigan's plans would likely be
approved, Flanagan was reluctant to dump on the federal agency.
"They are still trying to administer an NCLB that is in its
infancy," Flanagan said. "We just need to move on. A year from
now we'll be in good shape."
Board Presented Content Expectations For Science
The State Board of Education has already approved content
expectations for English, Language Arts, and Mathematics. Today
it got its first look at content expectations for Science. The
fourth and final expectations standards will be presented at the
Board's June meeting.
The content expectations for Science are divided into four
categories: Earth & Space Science, Biology, Physics and
Chemistry. There will be a prerequisite set of knowledge and
skills that a student must have in science, followed by an
"essential" set of knowledge and skills that requires two years
of general science and then a "core" set combined with the
"essential" in order to obtain a high school graduation credit
Sue CARNELL, the governor's education advisor, expressed concern
the document doesn't outline how to get from the teaching of
science to the "hands-on" lessons in the classroom.
Jeremy HUGHES, Department of Education chief academic officer,
said there are concerns being expressed by some schools about
putting all kids into biology, as the new graduation
requirements call for, when there may not be enough laboratory
"We need to demonstrate that there may be a number of ways that
may be less than the ideal of hands-on," Hughes said.
Board member Nancy DANHOF countered that the board "is shifting
from past ways to a new way of doing things" and expressed
concern that because of "flexibility" some school districts
might decide they don't have to have sufficient science labs.
Danhof suggested that this flexibility sets up a two-tier
situation: "Those who did well and those who almost got it."
The "draft" is being placed in the MDE Web site for public
comment and review through June. A final proposal will be
presented to the Board for approval at its August meeting.
Board Of Ed Meetings Being Video Streamed
Don't expect the viewings to top the Hollywood box office
blockbusters, but the State Board of Education meetings are now
being video streamed live.
The effort is a partnership between the Department of Education
and MI Streamnet to enable viewing of meetings from a desktop
computer. Archives of meetings will be available for a year.
back to the top ~
back to Breaking News
~ back to