Atlanta Schools Told to Pay up to $136,600 For Private Tuition:
Student's Dyslexia was Misdiagnosed
Kristina Torrds, The Atlanta
Journal-Constitution, March 23, 2007|
A federal judge has ordered Atlanta Public Schools to pay for a
former student misdiagnosed as mentally disabled to go to
private school to get his high school diploma.
The student, Jarron Draper, now 20, has been out of school since
June, stocking shelves at Target and working full time as a
security guard while he and his family fought for an education
that he hopes will get him into college.
School psychologists evaluated Draper as "mildly intellectually
disabled" in 1998, when he was a fourth-grader. Five years
later, he was still reading at about a third- or fourth-grade
level when he was found instead to have a learning disability:
By then, Draper was a rising 10th-grader at Benjamin E. Mays
That he was re-evaluated at all is owing to protests filed by
his aunt Denice Smith Morgan and his grandmother Hattie A.
Smith, who argued that his struggles had nothing to do with
The system also missed a federal mandate requiring the
re-evaluation of a special needs student every three years.
School system officials, through spokesman Joe Manguno, declined
comment Thursday except to say, "We have received the judge's
decision, we are reviewing it and we are considering our
The system could appeal.
According to U.S. District Judge Marvin Shoob's 55-page ruling,
Atlanta "failed to provide [Draper] with a basic floor of
opportunity" to get his education, as federal law requires. His
order in part upheld a ruling early last year by an
administrative state judge.
Both the system and Draper appealed that ruling, but for
different reasons. Their appeals are the reason Shoob reviewed
The system argued that school officials met their obligation to
give Draper a "free appropriate public education" as required by
the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.
They also protested the "remedy" offered Draper, which included
a cap of $15,000 a year — good up until June 2009 — toward
private school tuition, as well as $11,000 in reimbursement for
a family loan used to pay for a brief period of private
Draper appealed in large part because the money wasn't enough to
pay for the services he needed.
In his ruling, Shoob threw out the $11,000 reimbursement, saying
the amount was not properly documented.
However, Shoob ordered the system to pay at least $34,150
annually for up to four years as Draper attends the Cottage
School, an Atlanta private school, to get his high school
"All we wanted was for Jarron to be taught to read, get help
with his math and graduate with a degree that would help him get
into college," said Smith Morgan, whose return home to Atlanta
from a U.S. Air Force career prompted her involvement with her
"It was like fighting Goliath," she said. "They wouldn't provide
basic services to teach a child to read? We won. That says
The ruling comes as state lawmakers debate creating a program in
Georgia that would provide special education students with the
option of leaving public schools to attend private campuses
through a taxpayer-funded tuition voucher.
David M. Monde, a lawyer with Jones Day who represented Draper
and his family, said he didn't know if voucher proponents would
use the case as an example for their cause.
A commercial litigator by specialty, Monde has a 14-year-old son
with cerebral palsy and got involved with Draper's case through
a program at his firm that helps families with limited means.
"I know how frustrated parents get dealing with public systems
about their special needs children," Monde said. Shoob's order,
he said, "shows if parents fight hard enough, the courts will
insist school systems honor their obligation under the law."
Monde said he will ask the court to make the school system pay
Draper's attorney's fees, which he pegged to be in the low six
you for visiting
bridges4kids does not
necessarily agree with the content or subject matter of all
articles nor do we endorse any specific argument.
Direct any comments on articles to